Article
From Counting Vaccinations to Completing Immunisation: Why Health Systems Must Reward Continuity of Care
Haiti’s RBF 2.0 evaluation highlights why health systems must reward follow-up, continuity, and full immunisation rather than simply counting vaccinations.
By Results-Based Financing
Shifo Foundation
5 min read
A child receiving the first dose of a vaccine is an important public health milestone. But it is not the achievement we should ultimately be celebrating. The real measure of success is whether that child returns for every subsequent dose, completes the recommended immunisation schedule, and receives the protection that vaccination is intended to provide.
This distinction is becoming increasingly important for health systems across low- and middle-income countries. Recording a vaccination is relatively straightforward. Ensuring that families return, tracking children who miss appointments, and completing the entire immunisation journey require something much more fundamental: continuity of care.
Haiti's experience offers an interesting insight into why this matters. An evaluation of Haiti's Results-Based Financing (RBF 2.0) pilot, implemented across 19 health institutions in the North Department, identified a considerable gap between the initiation and completion of childhood immunisation.
The September 2025 findings are particularly revealing. Penta 1 performance reached just above half of the established RBF target, while Penta 3 achieved roughly one-third. The number of fully vaccinated children remained substantially below both the historical baseline and the programme target. In other words, the further a child progressed through the vaccination schedule, the wider the performance gap became.
This is not simply a question of how many vaccines are administered. It raises a more important question: are health systems equipped and incentivised to ensure that children complete the care they start?
The problem with measuring individual services
Traditional healthcare performance indicators often focus on individual service encounters. How many children received their first vaccine? How many antenatal consultations took place? How many patients visited a health facility? These numbers are useful. But they do not always tell us whether people received the complete care they needed.
A child receiving Penta 1 but missing subsequent doses represents an incomplete immunisation journey. Similarly, a pregnant woman attending her first antenatal appointment but missing follow-up visits cannot be considered a successful continuity-of-care outcome.
The distinction between service utilisation and effective health coverage is important.
The World Bank's research report, Improving Effective Coverage in Health: Do Financial Incentives Work?, makes an important contribution to this discussion. It examines why increased healthcare utilisation does not necessarily translate into better health outcomes and why coverage must be considered alongside the quality of care delivered.
This is precisely the challenge that immunisation programmes need to address.
What Haiti's RBF 2.0 experience tells us
Haiti's evaluation provides more than a snapshot of vaccination performance. It also demonstrates the importance of having reliable, individual-level health data to understand where patients are being lost along the care pathway. Under RBF 2.0, health institutions moved towards digitised service records, automated performance indicator calculations and electronic verification processes.
The evaluation found that more than 95% of clients had complete registration information, age was recorded for approximately 99% of registered clients, and unique medical identification records achieved 99% accuracy. Comparisons between paper forms and digitised records also showed 99% consistency. These findings matter because health systems cannot effectively track continuity of care without knowing who received a service, when they received it, and whether they returned.
Yet the immunisation findings highlight a different challenge. While the system was successfully capturing service delivery, completing multi-visit vaccination schedules remained difficult.
The evaluation also found that services integrated into routine facility visits performed relatively well, whereas indicators dependent on early contact and sustained community outreach struggled. The discontinuation of USAID-supported community activities was among the external factors affecting outreach-dependent services.
This suggests that digitalisation alone cannot close immunisation gaps. Reliable data must translate into action at the facility and community levels.
Should healthcare financing reward the entire care journey?
This is where Results-Based Financing (RBF 2.0) presents an opportunity for a broader rethink.
Instead of rewarding facilities primarily for individual service encounters, performance frameworks could place greater emphasis on continuity and completion. For immunisation, this could mean tracking:
- Children who receive Penta 1 and subsequently return for Penta 2 and Penta 3.
- Children who miss scheduled vaccination appointments.
- The proportion of children completing their full immunisation schedule.
- Timeliness of follow-up and successful defaulter tracing.
- Differences in completion rates across communities and health facilities.
Financial incentives could then recognise verified progress across the vaccination pathway, rather than treating every administered dose as an isolated achievement. However, this should not become another exercise in imposing targets on already stretched health workers. Facilities need the resources, staffing, vaccine availability, community outreach support and operational flexibility to deliver continuous care.
The World Bank's research on performance-based financing is relevant here. Its findings suggest that financial incentives alone are not necessarily the reason health programmes improve. Transparency, accountability, facility autonomy and stronger frontline financing also matter.
The objective, therefore, should be to build a system in which incentives support better care rather than simply generate more reported activities.
Data must lead to action, not just better reporting
One of the most important lessons from Haiti is that a digital health system becomes valuable when information helps healthcare workers make better decisions.
Knowing that a child missed Penta 2 should trigger a follow-up process. Identifying facilities with consistently low completion rates should lead to targeted supervision and support. Recognising communities with high dropout rates should prompt renewed outreach.
This requires connecting digital health records, routine immunisation services, community health workers and performance-based financing into a functioning continuum.
Haiti's RBF 2.0 evaluation also highlights improvements in administrative efficiency. Under stable operating conditions, the reporting-to-payment approval workflow was completed within 24–35 days. Its costing analysis estimated approximately 96% lower recurring operational costs at national scale compared with the earlier model. These are encouraging operational findings. But they should not be confused with proven improvements in immunisation outcomes.
The evaluation covered an early implementation period, during which RBF payments had not yet been regularly disbursed. It therefore establishes an operational foundation, not evidence that financial incentives have already improved vaccination completion.
That distinction is important when considering the model's potential for wider adoption.
Measuring what actually matters
The next generation of health financing needs to look beyond the number of consultations, vaccinations and services delivered. It needs to ask whether people received the care they needed, whether they returned when required and whether health systems remained accountable until the intended outcome was achieved.
For immunisation programmes, that means moving from counting first doses to tracking completion of the full vaccination schedule, ensuring timely follow-ups, reducing dropouts and reaching every eligible child with all the recommended doses.
About the author
Results-Based Financing
Shifo Foundation
Shifo Foundation's Results-Based Financing team works with governments to make performance-linked health financing accurate, timely and transparent.
LinkedInWant to discuss this with Shifo?
Get in touch with our team to talk about Results-Based Financing in your context.
Get in touch